Our Favorite Anna Maria Island Restaurant Recommendations

Anna Maria Island Restaurant Recommendations

Welcome to Anna Maria Island! We’re thrilled to provide you with some restaurant recommendations to make your dining experience on the island truly delightful. Please note that while we can’t make reservations for you, we’ve categorized these restaurants to help you find the perfect spot for your occasion. Please make sure you call ahead to inquire about the restaurants hours and ensure they will be open during your dates of travel, as many of businesses on the island have seasonal closings each year. 

Restaurants that are Known to Accept Reservations (to the best of our knowledge):

• Beach Bistro: Enjoy a fine dining experience with a Gulf-front view and a menu featuring fresh seafood and delectable wines.
• SALT Bar and Table: Savor creative dishes and craft cocktails at this contemporary restaurant known for its innovative flavors.
• Bridge Street Bistro: A waterfront gem offering American cuisine and a charming atmosphere. Ideal for special occasions.
• Blue Marlin: Casual yet sophisticated dining with a diverse menu, featuring seafood, steaks, and more.
• The Chateau Anna Maria: A cozy spot with a Mediterranean twist, perfect for intimate dinners and gatherings.
• The Porch: Relax on the porch with Southern-inspired dishes and cocktails in a laid-back setting.
• The Doctor’s Office: An intimate speakeasy-style restaurant with a unique menu and a great cocktail selection.

Restaurants on Anna Maria Island that are great for larger groups:

• The Sandbar: A beachfront restaurant with a relaxed vibe, offering seafood and American classics.
• The Ugly Grouper: Lively and spacious, this spot is perfect for groups looking for a fun atmosphere and great food.
• The Beach House: Enjoy beachfront dining with a diverse menu and stunning views of the Gulf.
• Swordfish Grill: A local favorite known for its seafood and waterfront seating.

Restaurants on Anna Maria Island that offer Beachfront or Water Views:

• The Waterfront Restaurant: Dine on fresh seafood while enjoying views of Tampa Bay.
• Island Ocean Star: Experience Asian-inspired cuisine with breathtaking Gulf views.
• Sandbar Seafood & Spirits: A classic beachfront restaurant with a seafood-focused menu.
• Bridge Tender Inn: Relax by the water and enjoy seafood specialties and live music.

Intimate & Romantic Restaurants on Anna Maria Island:

• The Chateau Anna Maria: A charming, intimate setting for a romantic evening.
• The Waterfront Restaurant: Perfect for a romantic dinner with waterfront views.
• Beach Bistro: Fine dining by the beach, ideal for a special occasion.
• The Doctors Office: A cozy spot for an intimate evening.
• Blue Marlin: Intimate setting with a focus on seafood.
• SALT Bar and Table: Upscale dining with a romantic atmosphere.
• Fifty-three Fifty The Pour House: An intimate option with diverse cuisine.

Notable Favorites for Smaller Groups on Anna Maria Island:

• Los Chiludos: Mexican cuisine in a friendly atmosphere.
• Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe: A sweet spot for desserts and more.
• Fifty-three Fifty The Pour House: Craft beer and delicious bites.
• Hurricane Hanks: Casual seafood dining with a local touch.
• Duffy’s Tavern: A classic pub experience with great food.
• La Creperie: French-inspired crepes for a unique taste.
• Mademoiselle Paris: Authentic French bakery and cafe.
• Ginny’s & Jane E’s Cafe: A beloved local spot for breakfast and lunch.
• Slim’s Place: A friendly neighborhood bar with good food.
• Skinny’s Place: Casual beachside dining with a local feel.
• Wicked Cantina: Mexican cuisine and a lively atmosphere.
• The Feast: A diverse menu with something for everyone.
• Bortell’s: A local favorite for pizza and Italian dishes.
• Harry’s Grill: A laid-back spot for seafood and drinks.
• Daiquiri Deck: Frozen drinks and seafood by the beach.
• Freckled Fin: Irish pub with a diverse menu.

Quick Bites and Grab-and-Go Meals on Anna Maria Island:

• Scott’s Deli: A local favorite for delicious deli sandwiches and quick, satisfying meals.
• Blueberries: Indulge in fresh and flavorful breakfast and lunch options at Blueberries.
• The General Store: Offers a variety of convenience items, snacks, and ready-to-eat options for a quick meal.
• Cheesecake Cutie:  Satisfy your sweet tooth with a delightful selection of cheesecakes and desserts.
• Graze Street AMI: Enjoy a diverse range of delectable options from gourmet sandwiches to salads and more.
• Pizza Social: For pizza lovers, Pizza Social is a must-visit, serving up mouthwatering pies with various toppings.
• Poppo’s Taqueria: Experience the flavors of Mexico with a diverse menu of tacos, burritos, and more.
• Vinny’s Italian Kitchen: Authentic Italian food, offers carry-out and most food can be ordered bake-at-home style.
• Topsail Steamer: Seafood steam pots prepared with fresh local seafood, meat and veggies and homemade spices to take home, steam, eat and enjoy!

Favorite Breakfast Restaurants on Anna Maria Island:

• Minnie’s Beach Cafe: Traditional american breakfast complete with grits, omlettes, and daily specials.
• Breakfast at Victoria’s: Farm to table approach serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner. 
• The Donut Experiment:We make the donuts fresh to order, you pick your toppings and flavors! Get ’em by the single, half dozen or dozen.
• Anna Maria Island Beach Cafe: All you can eat pancakes! Breakfast, lunch and dinner served on the beach. 
• Mademoiselle Paris: Authentic French bakery and cafe.
• La Creperie: French-inspired crepes for a unique taste.

Accessible by Water Surrounding Anna Maria Island:

• Island Ocean Star: Arrive by boat for a seafood feast.
• The Chateau Anna Maria: Waterfront dining accessible by boat.
• Floridays Woodfire Grill & Bar: Dock your boat and enjoy great food.
• Annie’s Bait & Tackle: A waterside dining option with a unique twist.
• Seafood Shack: Fresh seafood with boat-friendly access.
• Tide Tables: bayside dining for boaters.
• Star Fish Company: A classic seafood joint with boat slips.
• Swordfish Grill: Casual waterside dining for boaters.
• Cortez Kitchen: A local favorite with docking facilities. (RE-OPENING SOON)
• Anna Maria Oyster Bar: Arrive by boat for seafood and more.
• Bridge Tender Inn: Waterfront dining accessible by boat.
• Mar Vista Dockside Restaurant: Coastal dining with dock access.
• The Shore: Waterfront dining perfect for boaters.

Restaurants Just Off Anna Maria Island:

• Tide Tables: Riverside dining with a relaxed atmosphere.
• Slickers Eatery: A short drive away for great food.
• Swordfish Grill: Seafood spot with a lively atmosphere.
• The Shore: Waterfront dining near Anna Maria Island.
• Mar Vista Dockside Restaurant: Coastal dining on Longboat Key.
• Euphemia Hay Restaurant: A nearby option for fine dining.
• Star Fish Company: A seafood favorite close to the island.
• Cortez Cafe: A local favorite for breakfast and lunch just off Anna Maria Island in Cortez. 

Restaurants Worth the Drive Off Anna Maria Island:

• The Dry Dock: A classic seafood destination in Sarasota.
• Chateau 13: Fine dining experience worth the drive to downtown Bradenton.
• Euphemia Haye Restaurant: Exceptional cuisine in Longboat Key.
• Agrigento Pizzeria Caffe: Italian flavors in nearby Bradenton.
• Oak and Stone: Craft beer and pizza in Bradenton.

We hope you have a fantastic dining experience on Anna Maria Island! Please note that the availability of reservations may vary depending on the time of year and party size. We recommend reaching out to the restaurant directly to inquire about booking arrangements. We hope you have a fantastic dining experience on Anna Maria Island!

*Disclaimer: The information provided here is accurate as of our knowledge cutoff date in September 2023. Please verify details with the respective establishments for any potential changes.*