Unforgettable Culinary Delights:
Restaurant Recommendations on Anna Maria Island
Located along the breathtaking Gulf of Mexico, Anna Maria Island is a hidden gem on the Florida coast that offers not only pristine beaches and stunning sunsets but also a vibrant dining scene. With an array of delightful restaurants to choose from, each offering its unique ambiance and flavors, this blog post will serve as your ultimate guide to the best dining experiences on Anna Maria Island. From waterfront eateries to charming bistros, we’ve handpicked a selection of must-visit restaurants that are sure to tantalize your taste buds and leave you with unforgettable memories. Not listed in any specific order, below is a list of our favorite restaurants on Anna Maria Island. The list is not all inclusive of all the restaurants on the island, these are our favorites and go to spots! We hope you enjoy these restaurant recommendations, as much as we do!
For a more intimate and romantic dining experience, head to Beach Bistro. This elegant restaurant is renowned for its exceptional service and a menu that showcases the best of both land and sea. The culinary creations here are artfully presented, and each dish tells a story of the island’s flavors. Be sure to pair your meal with a fine wine from their extensive selection for a truly sophisticated dining affair. The lobster escargot are to die for!
As the name suggests, Waterfront Restaurant stands out for its stunning views of the azure Gulf waters. This upscale establishment boasts a delectable menu that focuses on locally-sourced ingredients, making it a top choice for seafood lovers. Whether you’re enjoying their famous crab cakes or savoring a perfectly seared catch of the day, dining at Waterfront is a true celebration of Anna Maria Island’s coastal charm. The seared tuna appetizer, and jalapeno margarita are the best of the island.
Duffy’s
Looking for a laid-back spot with a lively atmosphere? Duffy’s is your answer. This local favorite is a quintessential beachfront hangout that welcomes visitors with open arms. Offering a diverse menu featuring juicy burgers with chips, no fries here. Duffy’s caters to all tastes. Don’t miss their famous navy bean soup!
The Feast
Experience a culinary adventure at The Feast, where international flavors and creative fusion dishes take center stage. This eclectic restaurant offers a diverse menu that draws inspiration from various cuisines around the world. If you’re a foodie eager to try something new, The Feast is the place to be. Excellent pizza and my favorite greek salad on the island.
Craving a more casual setting with a selection of craft beers and comfort food? Look no further than The Pour House. This local hotspot offers a relaxed atmosphere, making it an ideal spot to unwind with friends or family. From their breakfast menu to their flavorful appetizers, The Pour House has all the makings of a memorable dining experience. My favorite matcha latte and meatballs on the island.
The Chateau Anna Maria
The Chateau Anna Maria exudes charm and elegance. Known for its charming outdoor seating, this restaurant serves up delicious dishes inspired by French and Italian cuisines. From grilled chateaubriand to truffled wild mushroom ravioli, indulge in classic European flavors while enjoying the island’s warm breeze. My favorite steak on the island, the chateaubriand.
The Porch
Embrace the island’s laid-back vibe at The Porch, a welcoming eatery that captures the essence of Anna Maria Island’s beachy lifestyle. Famous for its delectable lunch and dinner options, The Porch is the perfect place for a truly sought-after fine dining experience within one of the first homes built in Anna Maria. The best pork chop and house salad with the most perfectly prepared vinaigrette on the island.
Los Chiludos
For an authentic taste of Mexico, Los Chiludos is a must-visit. This vibrant Mexican restaurant boasts a menu filled with mouthwatering tacos, burritos, and sizzling fajitas. The lively atmosphere and colorful décor add to the overall fiesta experience. They have the absolute best chips and guacamole on the island!
Le Creperie
Indulge your sweet tooth at Le Creperie, a charming spot that specializes in French crepes and other delectable desserts. From savory options filled with savory delights to sweet crepes adorned with fresh fruits and creamy sauces, Le Creperie offers a delightful experience for every palate. The best chicken salad with balsamic vinaigrette, and savory crepes on the island.
Wicked Cantina
Craving Tex-Mex with a beachy twist? Wicked Cantina is your go-to spot. This lively eatery serves up Tex-Mex favorites like loaded nachos, sizzling fajitas, and zesty margaritas—all with a dash of coastal flair. The mango margarita with a sugar rim is my favorite!
Blue Marlin
As one of the island’s long-standing seafood restaurants, Blue Marlin has earned its reputation for serving some of the freshest catches in the region. Their seafood platters and seared fish dishes are simply divine, and the nautical-themed ambiance adds to the overall dining experience. The pecan crusted grouper is the best of the best!
Bridge Tender Inn
With its charming waterfront setting and old-Florida vibe, Bridge Tender Inn is a local favorite for both tourists and residents. Enjoy their delicious seafood dishes while watching boats sail by and soaking in the island’s natural beauty. Tasty nachos with chili and beans is my go to, the rueben with coleslaw is a household favorite for us!
Bridge Street Bistro
Perched along the bustling Bridge Street, this elegant bistro offers an upscale dining experience with a focus on fresh and seasonal ingredients. Savor delightful dishes while enjoying views of the bustling street and the nearby ocean.
Skinny’s Place
If you’re in the mood for some mouthwatering burgers and fries, Skinny’s is the place to be. This casual joint is beloved for its juicy burgers and a variety of toppings that cater to all tastes. My favorite buffalo chicken bites with ranch on the island.
The Cheese Cake Cutie & Cafe
Satisfy your sweet cravings with a visit to Cheese Cake Cutie. Indulge in a delectable selection of cheesecakes, each boasting unique flavors that will leave you craving for more. So much more than cheesecakes, don’t miss out on their delicious breakfast and lunch menu.
Sandbar Restaurant
End your culinary journey with a visit to Sandbar Restaurant, a delightful oceanfront eatery with an inviting atmosphere. Known for its toes-in-the-sand dining experience, Sandbar offers a delectable menu with a focus on fresh seafood and tropical-inspired dishes. The best roasted brussell sprouts on the island!
Restaurant recommendations on Anna Maria Island
Anna Maria Island’s diverse dining scene has something to offer every food lover. From waterfront seafood havens to charming bistros and casual beachfront hangouts, the island’s restaurants cater to various tastes and preferences. So, whether you’re a seafood enthusiast, an international cuisine connoisseur, or simply looking to unwind with a refreshing beverage, these restaurant recommendations from Concierge AMI will undoubtedly make your visit to Anna Maria Island an unforgettable culinary journey. Bon appétit!
